Featured Pathways

More pathways

Banking Essentials - Part I

This pathway will walk us through the basics of banks, starting with some of the different types and their main functions, then starting to look at the regulation faced by the banks, both before and after the Global Financial Crisis.

Greenwashing

Greenwashing is the act of distributing false information about something being more environmentally friendly than it actually is.

More pathways

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

Plans & Membership

Our Platform

Expert led content

+1,000 expert presented, on-demand video modules

Learning analytics

Keep track of learning progress with our comprehensive data

Interactive learning

Engage with our video hotspots and knowledge check-ins

Testing & certification

Gain CPD / CPE credits and professional certification

Managed learning

Build, scale and manage your organisation’s learning

Integrations

Connect Finance Unlocked to your current platform

Featured Content

More featured content

Tackling the Cost of Living Crisis

In this video, Max discusses the cost-of-living crisis currently enveloping the UK. He examines its impact on households as well as the overall economy.

CSR and Sustainability in Financial Services

In the first video of this two-part video series, Elisa introduces us to sustainability. She begins by looking at the difference between sustainability and corporate social responsibility, two terms that can be easily confused.

More featured content

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

Featured Pathways

More pathways

Banking Essentials - Part I

This pathway will walk us through the basics of banks, starting with some of the different types and their main functions, then starting to look at the regulation faced by the banks, both before and after the Global Financial Crisis.

Greenwashing

Greenwashing is the act of distributing false information about something being more environmentally friendly than it actually is.

More pathways

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

Plans & Membership

Our Platform

Expert led content

+1,000 expert presented, on-demand video modules

Learning analytics

Keep track of learning progress with our comprehensive data

Interactive learning

Engage with our video hotspots and knowledge check-ins

Testing & certification

Gain CPD / CPE credits and professional certification

Managed learning

Build, scale and manage your organisation’s learning

Integrations

Connect Finance Unlocked to your current platform

Featured Content

More featured content

Tackling the Cost of Living Crisis

In this video, Max discusses the cost-of-living crisis currently enveloping the UK. He examines its impact on households as well as the overall economy.

CSR and Sustainability in Financial Services

In the first video of this two-part video series, Elisa introduces us to sustainability. She begins by looking at the difference between sustainability and corporate social responsibility, two terms that can be easily confused.

More featured content

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

Book a demo

Pricing

Ready to get started?

The Failure of Silicon Valley Bank

The Failure of Silicon Valley Bank

January Carmalt

20 years: Research & banking

In this video, January discusses the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB), its failed risk management, and dubious asset and liability management practices sealing its demise. She also explores the misguided assumptions behind the structural hedging undertaken by the bank, the bank’s economic value of equity (or EVE) measurements and confusion surrounding its risk exposure. Finally, she highlights the lessons that should be learned from the SVB collapse, emphasising the importance of effective risk management, understanding the deposit base, and not running large open risks in the banking book.

In this video, January discusses the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SVB), its failed risk management, and dubious asset and liability management practices sealing its demise. She also explores the misguided assumptions behind the structural hedging undertaken by the bank, the bank’s economic value of equity (or EVE) measurements and confusion surrounding its risk exposure. Finally, she highlights the lessons that should be learned from the SVB collapse, emphasising the importance of effective risk management, understanding the deposit base, and not running large open risks in the banking book.

Now free to watch

This video is now available for free. It is also part of a premium, accredited video course. Sign up for a 7-day free trial to watch more.

The Failure of Silicon Valley Bank

16 mins 28 secs

Overview

Silicon Valley Bank's collapse serves as a warning for the financial system, as it highlights the risks of mismanagement and a crisis of confidence. The bank's failed risk management and asset-liability management practices sealed its demise, as it invested the majority of its deposits in long-term, fixed-rate bonds without proper hedging and oversight, leaving it exposed to interest rate risk. The collapse was also driven by sector concentration risk, as most of the bank's depositors were from the tech industry. The lessons to be learned include the importance of effective risk management, understanding the deposit base, and not running large open risks in the banking book.

Key learning objectives:

  • Understand the causes of the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank, including failed risk management and ALM practices

  • Outline why investing deposits long-term for a fixed rate isn’t sensible

  • Outline the key learnings from the SVB collapse

Now free to watch

This video is now available for free. It is also part of a premium, accredited video course. Sign up for a 7-day free trial to watch more.

Summary

Why were SVBs risk management and ALM practices flawed?

SVB's risk management and ALM practices were flawed because they invested a majority of the sharp increase in deposits (+$89bn in 2021) in long-term, fixed-rate bonds without proper hedging or oversight, leaving them exposed to interest rate risk. 

As interest rates rose sharply, the market value of the bonds dropped substantially, exposing an existential hole in its solvency. SVB lacked adequate liquid assets to cover the quantum of withdrawals as depositors headed for the exits en masse, forcing the bank to realise the very losses that prompted the exodus.

How did SVB approach its structural hedging and what misguided assumptions did it follow? 

SVB approached its structural hedging by applying a simplistic risk management technique of "structural/margin compression hedging" of non-maturity deposits. This requires a clear demonstration of deposit stability, a clear grasp of concentration risk, and properly forecasting the investment horizon, which are all required for normal ALM practice. 

However, SVB lacked the observable trends and past behaviour of its largely VC and cash-strapped tech start-up client base, and it is unclear whether these considerations were made. SVB's misguided assumptions included endorsing this simplistic technique without undertaking basic checks and implicitly assuming deposit stability for an extended period.

What was SVB’s economic value of equity? 

The Economic Value of Equity (EVE) measurement published in SVB's 2021 annual report indicated that the bank had a value-at-risk of $5.7bn, which represented 34% of its capital base of $16.6bn in the event of a 200 basis point rate shock. It is unclear how the numbers were computed and whether any behavioural maturity was assigned to non-interest-bearing deposits. The bank entered into swaps to reduce rate risk in March 2021, indicating an awareness of the risk to its EVE and its size. However, SVB did not publish its EVE sensitivities in its 2022 annual report and accounts.

What were the drivers of deposit outflows from SVB?

During 2022, total customer deposits declined from $189bn to $173bn. Even more critically, the mix altered: as non-interest-bearing deposits fell from $125bn to just $81bn while interest-bearing deposits increased from $63bn to $92bn. The outflow of over a third of SVB’s non-interest-bearing deposits during 2022 was driven by depositors being more rate sensitive than forecasted, as well as the concentration risk of depositors stemming from the tech sector, many of whom were individual owners and stakeholders in the industry. Additionally, during 2022 as rates increased, recession risk loomed and macro-sentiment shifted, resulting in a decline in equity capital raising for start-ups and a decrease in deposits. The lack of diversification of SVB's depositor base in one sector contributed to this vulnerability.

What are the key lessons to be learned from the SVB collapse? 

Key lessons from the SVB collapse: 

1. Avoid large open risks in the banking-book for short term gain

2. Ensure competent independent risk management 

3. Don't exceed risk appetites without loss-absorbing capacity 

4. Unremunerated cash deposits may not stay long-term 

5. Properly analyse NMD portfolio before hedging 

Now free to watch

This video is now available for free. It is also part of a premium, accredited video course. Sign up for a 7-day free trial to watch more.

January Carmalt

January Carmalt

January began her career in 1999 with Bank of America in Charlotte, NC. From the Credit Products team, she moved into fixed income bond research covering Telecoms and Financials. While in London, January focused on financial institutions bond research until her Director and head bond analyst role at Deutsche Bank. As of 2011, January has worked as a freelance writer.

There are no available videos from "January Carmalt"